Twenty-two launches: a number that demands attention
The latest internal NASA estimate puts a stark figure on what it will take to land astronauts on the Moon during Artemis IV: twenty-two Starship launches. Each one would carry cryogenic propellant — liquid methane and liquid oxygen — to an orbital depot, gradually building up enough fuel to power SpaceX's Human Landing System before it begins its descent to the lunar surface. That number has grown considerably from earlier public projections, which had already raised eyebrows by suggesting around ten refueling flights.
The underlying challenge is well understood but far from solved. Cryogenic propellant transfer in orbit has never been demonstrated at the scale that Artemis IV would require. Liquid methane and liquid oxygen are notoriously difficult to store in space without significant boil-off losses. Every day the propellant sits in orbit, some of it evaporates. String twenty-two launches across weeks or months, and the margins become very tight indeed. As one NASA official was recently quoted as saying, the agency needs to keep close watch on the number of required fueling operations for the lander.
NASA's safety watchdog steps in
The Aerospace Safety Advisory Panel — ASAP — is NASA's independent advisory body tasked with evaluating program-level risks. According to recent reporting, the panel is on the verge of issuing a formal recommendation calling on NASA to take a hard look at the current Artemis IV plan, which envisions a crewed landing near the lunar South Pole.
ASAP is not questioning the broader goals of the Artemis program, but the panel is concerned that building a mission around an unproven, multi-launch propellant logistics chain introduces layers of systemic risk that are genuinely difficult to quantify. If any one of those twenty-two launches fails, or if propellant losses exceed modeled tolerances, the entire mission timeline unravels. Separately, the panel is reported to have raised concerns about NASA's longer-term access to low Earth orbit, particularly as the International Space Station moves closer to its planned deorbit at the end of the decade.
A schedule already under pressure
Artemis IV occupies a critical position in the program sequence. It is intended to be the first mission to use the Starship HLS for a crewed lunar landing, building on a shorter surface demonstration planned for Artemis III. But Artemis milestones have slipped repeatedly, and no official revised target date for Artemis IV has been announced. People familiar with internal discussions suggest NASA is acutely aware of the widening gap between stated ambitions and demonstrated technical readiness.
SpaceX continues to advance Starship's development through its ongoing test flight campaign, but a full orbital propellant transfer demonstration has not yet taken place. That validation must happen — and happen reliably — before NASA can commit to any credible launch manifest for Artemis IV.
The question ASAP is pressing NASA to answer is deceptively straightforward: is it responsible to plan a crewed lunar mission around a refueling architecture that has not yet been proven to work? How the agency responds in the coming months will say a great deal about where Artemis is actually headed.


